In which Tamara ponders the writer's life and the world around her.
January 1, 2014
December 10, 2013
The Responsibilities of Writers
Labels:
the writing life
This morning, NPR interviewed David Simon, writer and producer of The Wire, and Azar Nafisi, author of Reading Lolita in Tehran, about the effect of the NSA surveillance on writers. Nafisi talked about how she’s heard of poets who censor themselves because of the NSA surveillance, and Simon talked about how writers have a responsibility to write anyway. That got me thinking about the responsibilities that writers have.
1. To
write. First and foremost, writers have a responsibility to write. They have a talent, a skill, and they should
use that skill. The only way to be a
writer, after all, is to write. Think of how what you’ve read has deeply
affected you and what would have happened had that author not written whatever
it is? Your words may have the same effect, and therefore you have a responsibility to your readers.
2. To
be brave. It’s easy to write what’s easy, not to push yourself, not to edit as
much as you need to, not to reveal what you need to. I believe in prudence ~ do no harm ~ but always
ask yourself: “Am I holding back because of my concern for others, or am I just
not being brave?” As Anne Lamott says, “You own everything that happened to
you. Tell your stories. If people wanted you to write warmly about them, they
should have behaved better.” Besides, your best material often comes from what shakes you to the core.
3. To
be honest and truthful. By this, I don’t mean not to write science fiction ~
science fiction is more emotionally truthful than some other types of
writing. What I mean is that if you
write false, the reader will see right through you. You may think you’re being clever, but readers
are much smarter than some people give them credit for. Don’t talk down and push yourself to be as
accurate and honest as possible.
4. To
be clear. I’ve found that when people
use circuitous language, it’s often because they either don’t understand what
it is they are trying to convey or they haven’t thought it through or they're being untruthful. Others use fancy
language when they’re trying to impress people ~ don’t do that. You just come across as unintelligible and
pompous. On the other hand, there are things that are hard to convey, and so
you have the responsibility of working even harder to convey them clearly.
5. To
write to the best of their ability and to continue to improve their craft. We need to write well, and so we need to
always be working to get better at what we do.
10,000 hours, and all that. And
as Gladwell says, it not only has to be practice, but you have to challenge
yourself and find mentors, if you can.
6. To
consider the rhetorical situation, especially audience. Unless
you’re writing totally for yourself ~ which is fine, too ~ you have to
consider the needs of an audience. I
think of it as a sin, in fact. You also
need to consider the genre you’re writing in and what you’re trying to
achieve. “Everything is an argument,” as
they say, and you need to use all your tools to convince your readers.
7. To
represent the interests of their client, much like a lawyer. Sometimes we’re not writing for ourselves,
and there’s no shame in that. Writing
for money isn’t bad. In that case, we
need to put our own needs and agendas aside and consider those of the people we
represent above all else. There are many
writers who consider this their highest calling ~ to represent an organization and
change the world.
8. To
entertain. Be not boring. This came as a surprise to students when I
taught freshman comp. You not only have
to write well, but you have to try to engage your audience. It helps if you’re engaged with the subject
yourself, and I’ve never found a subject that didn’t engage me in some way once
I got into it.
9. To
be good literary citizens. Writing is by
nature a solitary pursuit, and so it’s easy to become isolated. I think we have a responsibility to help
other writers ~ whether it’s volunteering at a grade school or giving other
writers feedback and encouraging them or running a litmag or something
else.
You’ll notice what’s not on this list.
1. To
follow your heart. I'm not saying not to write what you want, but, you know what,
sometimes you just need to write for money to feed your family, and what’s more
noble than that? Also, writing is 5% inspiration and 95% perspiration, as they
say ~ trust your fingers, not your heart.
2. To
write what you know. There is truth in
this, in that you should write clearly and truthfully. However, don’t let this dictum confine
you. You’re a white male surburban
kid? You don’t have to write just about
white male suburban kids. What I take
from this is to write what you care about and write about it truthfully.
3. To
be likable. We have no responsibility to
be likable and in some situations we have a duty to shake people out of their
complacency. I think this is a hard one
for some women writers, including myself.
4. To
create likable characters. Likable can
be very boring. Claire Messud said it best: “For heaven’s sake, what kind of question is that? Would you want to be friends with Humbert Humbert? Would you want to be friends with Mickey Sabbath? Saleem Sinai? Hamlet? Krapp? Oedipus? Oscar Wao? Antigone? Raskolnikov? Any of the characters in The Corrections? Any of the characters in Infinite Jest? Any of the characters in anything Pynchon has ever written? Or Martin Amis? Or Orhan Pamuk? Or Alice Munro, for that matter? If you’re reading to find friends, you’re in deep trouble. We read to find life, in all its possibilities. The relevant question isn’t ‘is this a potential friend for me?’ but ‘is this character alive?’”
5. To
fight for the underdog ~ or the top dog, for that matter. By this, I mean we need to question our
knee-jerk reactions, and we don’t have a responsibility to have a certain take
on things. We as Americans tend to go for the underdog,
but sometimes the establishment is trying to do good in the world too, and
maybe they need to be represented.
6. To
be moral. I recently read this on the
interwebs: “A writer should change readers into better humans.” Bullshit. You can try to do this, sure, but there are
many other goals in writing, and much writing that has changed the world has
been considered immoral by the people of its time. Harm no innocents, surely, but also don’t
be afraid to tell your truth, as most likely it’s someone else’s truth.
December 5, 2013
'Argos' by Michael Collier
Labels:
poetry
I love this poem.
![]() |
| (via) |
ARGOS
by Michael Collier
If you think Odysseus too strong and brave to cry,
that the god-loved, god-protected hero
when he returned to Ithaka disguised,
intent to check up on his wife
and candidly apprize the condition of his kingdom,
steeled himself resolutely against surprise
and came into his land cold-hearted, clear-eyed,
ready for revenge--then you read Homer as I did,
too fast, knowing you'd be tested for plot
and major happenings, skimming forward to the massacre,
the shambles engineered with Telemakhos
by turning beggar and taking up the challenge of the bow.
Reading this way you probably missed the tear
Odysseus shed for his decrepit dog, Argos,
who's nothing but a bag of bones asleep atop
a refuse pile outside the palace gates. The dog is not
a god in earthly clothes, but in its own disguise
of death and destitution is more like Ithaka itself.
And if you returned home after twenty years
you might weep for the hunting dog
you long ago abandoned, rising from the garbage
of its bed, its instinct of recognition still intact,
enough will to wag its tail, lift its head, but little more.
Years ago you had the chance to read that page more closely
but instead you raced ahead, like Odysseus, cocksure
with your plan. Now the past is what you study,
where guile and speed give over to grief so you might stop,
and desiring to weep, weep more deeply.
If you think Odysseus too strong and brave to cry,
that the god-loved, god-protected hero
when he returned to Ithaka disguised,
intent to check up on his wife
and candidly apprize the condition of his kingdom,
steeled himself resolutely against surprise
and came into his land cold-hearted, clear-eyed,
ready for revenge--then you read Homer as I did,
too fast, knowing you'd be tested for plot
and major happenings, skimming forward to the massacre,
the shambles engineered with Telemakhos
by turning beggar and taking up the challenge of the bow.
Reading this way you probably missed the tear
Odysseus shed for his decrepit dog, Argos,
who's nothing but a bag of bones asleep atop
a refuse pile outside the palace gates. The dog is not
a god in earthly clothes, but in its own disguise
of death and destitution is more like Ithaka itself.
And if you returned home after twenty years
you might weep for the hunting dog
you long ago abandoned, rising from the garbage
of its bed, its instinct of recognition still intact,
enough will to wag its tail, lift its head, but little more.
Years ago you had the chance to read that page more closely
but instead you raced ahead, like Odysseus, cocksure
with your plan. Now the past is what you study,
where guile and speed give over to grief so you might stop,
and desiring to weep, weep more deeply.
December 4, 2013
'I Love Deadlines'
Labels:
cool people
![]() |
| Douglas Adams (via) |
"I love deadlines. I like the whooshing sound they make as they fly by." ~ Douglas Adams
December 3, 2013
Agreements
Labels:
culture and society
![]() |
| Not actually my son ;) (via) |
My son’s been giving me a bad time lately. He’ll say, “Mommy, it’s all your fault.” He’ll drop his bread on the floor or make a mess or nothing at all will happen, and he’ll say, “It’s your fault, Mommy.” He’s joking, I know he’s joking, and he knows that I know he’s joking. All in good fun, and we laugh.
But I was thinking about the social agreements we make, the
way we agree on what’s “normal” and what’s acceptable ~ which amounts to the
assumptions we make. You know how a couple will have a certain way they do
things. She stays at home with the kids
and does all the housework and he goes out to his job but doesn’t have to do
any housework or “help” with the kids.
Or he does the cooking and she does the laundry and they share taking
care of the kids. Or he’s the primary
caregiver to the kids because she can’t handle it for long. You get the
picture.
We personally have these agreements between us, but then
society, too, has agreements. The
idealized nuclear family is an agreement: wife keeps the home and kids while husband
goes to a job outside the home. All this
is, however, is an agreement, and these things change over time.
What’s interesting about all this is that we often take
those agreements we’ve been handed by our parents and never question them. The nuclear family is how it “should”
be. Two people of the same sex having a
loving relationship and getting married? Inconceivable. It’s inconceivable because that’s the
agreement we’ve inherited and we take the status quo as “normal” and “acceptable,”
and anything outside that is “unnatural” or the other.
I was particularly struck yesterday by a number of articles
I read that illustrated this. One was
from the Guardian ~ and I can’t seem to find it now ~ about a man who raped and
killed his wife. The point of the opinion
piece was that we blame the rape victim and tell her (or him) that they should
have done something different, that it was their fault. By saying that, we’re setting normal that
way, rather than saying the rapist is the one who is responsible for his own
actions. He (and it is most often a “he”)
should be held accountable rather than the victim. Another was about the practice of
gaslighting, named from the iconic 1944 MGM film, where you call a person crazy
and discount their feelings and thoughts so much that they question their own
impulses. A third one was about a woman
who witnessed a man undermining another young woman and her writing, and how
the woman took the chance and pointed out the gaslighting. A lot in the news
about this type lately.
It takes a lot to change these givens. First you’ve got to understand what’s going
on and then you’ve got to call people out on it. You’ve got to make boundaries and change
normal to something that takes your reality into account. It’s really hard to do ~ on a personal level
and on a societal level.
That’s a little of what my son is doing ~ gaslighting. We all do it to varying degrees. It’s all in good fun, but it’s also a way to
control your world, to try to get your way.
It’s a way to nudge the agreement.
December 2, 2013
The Stories Don’t Suck
Labels:
editing
![]() |
| (via) |
It was a great Thanksgiving. Amid driving to Omaha, eating deep-fried turkey and Guinness cake, seeing Frozen in 3D with cousins, and talking nonstop, I edited through my story collection. Only one more story to go and I’ll have an almost final draft!
One thing that was cool about it was I used my Asus Infinity
tablet with a docking station/keyboard to do it. It was a little slow, but so totally worth it
with the portability and flexibility. I
loved being able to sit at the dining room table with everyone around and work
and then have it in the car on the way there and back. Very productive. The Word I use (Kingsoft Office) does not
have full capabilities and takes a little to get used to, but it worked great.
But the thing I loved most was the thing that inevitably
happens: the stories didn’t suck. Most writers I know are like this. They write something, and they may think it’s
good or not. But the more time that passes, the more they are convinced that
the story is absolutely no good and they’ll be mortified when they go back and
read it. But when they do finally go
back ~ you know what? ~ they’re not so bad.
In fact, some of them are decent.
That was my experience this weekend editing through my
stories. Some of them needed some work,
especially the oldest ones, but the newer ones weren't half bad!
October 28, 2013
'A Gardener Is an Artist'
Labels:
history
Reading a fabulous nonfiction/popular history For All the Tea in China: How England Stole the World's Favorite Drink and Changed History by Sarah Rose. Fascinating stuff. And this passage, wow!
![]() |
| Butchart Gardens (via) |
“Although science was very much at the core of Fortune’s work, he was at heart a gardener, and a gardener is an artist: His canvas is land; his medium, plants. A gardenre works in a three-dimensional world, taking into account the relative heights of trees and depths of borders, the slope of a hillside, and the views to be ‘borrowed’ or enhanced. But he works in a fourth dimension as well: time. A gardner plans for seasons: which trees will bloom in spring (forsythia, magnolia, cherry, lilac, and apple) and which will reach their peak of color in autumn (acer, euonymus, and elder). A gardner’s art also spans years ~ in determining which trees mature quickly and grow tall easily, such as birch, ash, and the softwood evergreens such as cedqar, fir, and pine, and which grow slowly and with some effort to leave a lasting legacy, such as oak, beech,a nd maple, which stand for generations. Fortune was well aware that to be a great gardener demanded great patience.” ~ Sarah Rose, For All the Tea in China: How England Stole the World's Favorite Drink and Changed History
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






